26 Mar The 15 Best Gelato and Ice Cream in New York
New York City never disappoints when it comes to food: pizzas, French toast, bagels, cheesecakes, or gelato. Many of you might be amazed to see how great the ice cream vibes are in NYC, both in terms of taste and environment.
With so many great options of ice cream in NYC, it becomes difficult to choose where to go. Fortunately for you, we have listed the top 15 best ice cream shops in NYC by categorizing them according to their location.
Best Ice Cream Shops in Manhattan, NYC
Morgenstern`s Finest Ice Cream
There is no need to look beyond Morgenstern for someone looking for the best ice cream in Manhattan. You will find more than 80 wonderful flavors of ice cream, each individually twisted by the founder, Nicholas Morgenstern.
Whether you choose a traditional flavor like chocolate and vanilla or their innovative flavors such as burnt sage, your taste buds are going to be thankful anyway. To serve you the freshest ice cream, they make it in small batches. You will get a rush of nostalgia if you visit this place regardless of the flavor you choose.
- 2 Rivington St, New York, NY, USA
- +1 212 209 7684
- 12 pm – 10 pm, Monday – Sunday.
Serving the traditional ice cream for the past 30 years in the East Side Manhattan, Sedutto has a plethora of flavors to choose from. They are best known for their soft and hard serve yogurt and ice cream scoops, but they also sell their special drinks and desserts.
The most noticeable flavors of ice cream at Sedutto are blueberry, cookie dough, sea salt caramel, pistachio, vanilla oreo, and many more. You can celebrate special occasions with your loved ones by ordering from their delightful cakes and pie menu.
- 1498 1st Avenue no. 1, New York, NY, USA
- +1 212 879 9557
- 12 pm – 11:30 pm, Monday – Sunday.
Il Laboratorio Del Gelato
Pay a visit to Il laboratorio del gelato if you are ready to be blown away by this lab-looking gelato place in East Side Manhattan. You can explore their menu for all the incredible flavors they have to offer for gelato, shakes, sorbets, ice creams, and frozen treats.
Some of their exclusive flavors include cheddar cheese, mascarpone, olive oil, ricotta, and brown butter. They always keep on rotating their flavors, so you might not get the same flavor everyday.
- 188 Ludlow St, New York, NY, USA
- +1 212 343 9922
- 12 pm – 9 pm, Monday – Sunday.
Mikey Likes It Ice Cream
Founded by a native New Yorker and a pop lover, Michael Cole, this gelato shop has two locations in Manhattan, one in Harlem and the other one in Lower East Side. Mikey Likes It is not just any ice cream shop, it is a complete vibe, offering the authentic favorites of the native New Yorkers. Mikey is the true magician when it comes to creating new and innovative flavors, such as Brady Bunch, Pink Floyd, Dough Boy, and Jack & Jill.
- 199 Avenue A, New York, NY, USA
- +1 212 673 0199
- 10 am – 9 pm, Monday – Saturday. 2 pm – 10 pm, Sunday.
The Original Chinatown Ice Cream Factory
This historical ice cream shop located in the famous Chinatown of Manhattan has been serving the most incredible Chinese icy treats since 1978. The flavors that are served in the Original Chinatown Ice Cream Factory are highly uncommon yet delicious.
Their specialty is the zen butter, but none of their other flavors will be any less of a surprise. They have all the American flavors like banana, mango, and vanilla, and their regulars include black sesame, pandan, and lychee.
- 65 Bayard St, New York, NY, USA
- +1 212 608 4170
- 11 am – 9 pm, Monday – Thursday. 11 am – 10 pm, Friday – Sunday.
Best Ice Cream Shops in Brooklyn, NYC
Van Leeuwen Ice Cream
Van Leeuwen has come a long way from selling ice creams in its yellow truck to having multiple branches across NYC. With an aim to create the best feel-good ice cream in town, this shop started selling ice cream in 2008.
Their classic ice cream combinations are cookie and cream, peanut butter brownie chip, caramel cookie, and many more. Their menu is full of vegan ice cream options as well as other treats like sundaes and milkshakes.
- 81 Bergen St, Brooklyn, NY, USA
- +1 347 763 2979
- 12 pm – 11 pm, Monday – Sunday.
Odd Fellows Ice Cream Co
This small-batch ice cream shop that started from scratch is now one of the finest ice cream parlors in Brooklyn. At Odd Fellows, you get more than 500 different choices of some really creative and yummy flavor blends.
The not-so-odd fellow behind all those delicious flavors is the pastry chef Sam Mason, with multiple awards and international recognitions. Vanilla bean, black pepper fig, miso cherry, and cookies & cream are some of their noticeable flavors.
- 44 Water St, Brooklyn, NY, USA
- +1 718 683 5755
- 1 pm – 8 pm, Sunday – Thursday. 1 pm – 9 pm, Friday and Saturday.
Blue Marble Ice Cream
With a mission to provide high-quality and healthy ice cream in Brooklyn, Jennie and Alexis started this amazing shop called Blue Marble ice cream. This ice cream parlor makes delicious scoops of ice cream and gelato using local organic ingredients from the farms.
Their mission is to make the world a better place and spread joy through their organic ice cream. Several restaurants and food marts all across NYC sell their special ice cream. Apart from ice cream, they have pints, shakes, and much more. Head over now to get yourself a special treat.
- 186 Underhill Ave, Brooklyn, NY, USA
- +1 718 399 6926
- 8 am – 9 pm, Monday – Thursday. 9 am – 9 pm, Friday – Sunday.
Cream and Cocoa Creamery
If you are looking for some classic ice cream with a trendy twist at a reasonable price, Cream and Cocoa Creamery is your go-to place. Founded by a sweet couple, Omar and Astrid, this shop started selling ice cream in Brooklyn in 2017.
Since then, it has introduced some extremely delightful flavors with a fresh aroma. Here you can get all of the traditional flavors like vanilla and chocolate, but their specials are made with tropical fruits like mangoes and pineapples.
- 1067 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY, USA
- +1 718 245 6286
- 3 pm – 8 pm, Friday – Sunday.
Davey’s Ice Cream
This frosty magical place in the East Village can easily be called the best ice cream shop in Brooklyn. Each of their small ice cream batches takes up to four days to get that creamy, rich and magical flavor.
You get the scoops that are made right there in front of you with their heavenly freshness and aroma. The East Villagers’ flavors enjoy the most from Davey’s ice cream are a chocolate chunk, cinnamon-maple, and roasted pistachio.
- 74 Meserole Ave, Brooklyn, NY, USA
- +1 718 609 6066
- 1 pm – 8 pm, Monday – Thursday. 1 pm – 10 pm, Friday – Sunday.
Best Ice Cream Shops in Queens, NYC
Pesso’s Ices and Ice Cream
If you are a homemade ice cream kinda person, we suggest you get your ice cream from Pesso‘s as they make lovely homemade ice creams and gelato. Using the best raw ingredients from the local dairy farms in NYC, they make ice cream in small portions to serve you the freshest ice cream.
They never stick with the same flavors. Instead, keep on experimenting with creating something new out of the classic ones. Pesso’s has now become a famous landmark in Brooklyn and is definitely worth your time.
- 203-20 35th Ave, Queens, NY, USA
- +1 718 224 9130
- 2 pm – 10 pm, Monday – Sunday.
Ample Hills Creamery
They are making history in the ice cream scene of NYC by launching their own registered dairy plant and being unbeatable in serving the freshest ice cream. They make their ice creams with innovative ideas intending to sell the best ice cream in town.
Ample Hills Creamery has multiple branches in the city, in case you are ready to get up and have some of their ice creams. The interior of this ice cream shop is sophisticated with its cozy sitting and decent design.
- 34-20 30thAve, Queens, NY, USA
- +1 347 507 0770
- 1 pm – 9 pm, Monday – Thursday. 1 pm – 10 pm, Friday – Sunday.
Eddies Sweet Shop
If you want to get the nostalgic feeling of the old-school ice cream and want to revive the summer vibes of childhood, head over to Eddie Sweet Shop. Their ice cream takes you on a memory lane and gives you a sugary rush down the spine.
They have been in the market for over a hundred years, so they do know how to make top-notch ice cream and gelato. People from the older generations know this place by heart, yet you will see this place crowded with Gen Z.
- 105-29 Metropolitan Ave, Queens, NY, USA
- +1 718 520 8514
- 3 pm – 9 pm, Tuesday – Sunday. Mondays are closed.
Max and Mina’s Ice Cream
Selling ice cream with more than 500 flavors, Max and Mina’s ice cream has been in the market for decades. This family-owned ice cream parlor started making ice cream in 1997 and has only gotten better. They have some unconventional yet enjoyable flavors, such as cranberry vodka, lox, and pizza.
Don’t be afraid to try some of their uncommon flavors, but they do have all the classic flavors, too for all those who want to stick to the original taste. You get a nice artsy feel with the sweet smell of cream and dairy when you enter this place.
- 2023 7126 Main St, Flushing, NY, USA
- +1 718 793 8629
- 12 pm – 8 pm, Sunday – Thursday. 8:30 am – 11 pm, Saturday. Fridays are closed.
Mara’s Ice Cream Parlor
Located on Beech Street, this ice cream parlor has been serving the finest ice cream in town. Mara’s Ice cream parlor is a family-run shop with a mission to sell the most delicious icy treats. Their shop gives out a fun look with its large space for you to enjoy their wide range of flavors.
You will never find this place empty, as it is a fun hub for the millennials and generation Z because of the free WIFI. They have all the classic flavors like chocolate, vanilla, mango, and strawberry.
- 92-14 Rockaway Beach, NY, USA
- +1 718 474 2268
- 3 pm – 9 pm, Monday – Friday. 2 pm – 10 pm, Saturday – Sunday.